This post is part of Fight Back Fridays, hosted by Food Renegade.

The economy is very much in the news, and our personal economies are probably on the forefront of our thinking. The first question I am asked when I talk about belonging to a Community Supported Agriculture program is unvaryingly, “Wow, isn’t that expensive?”
Let’s break it down.
My vegetable CSA full share provides me a half bushel of in-season organically grown vegetables once a week for 24 consecutive weeks. I pay the farmer $700 in April.
The farm from which my veggies come is certified organic and always has been. They have healthy farm practices like crop rotation and use of beneficial insects. I enjoy talking to the farmer and his assistants when I pick up my share. He cheerfully answers my questions about his farming practices, varieties he grows and pending legislation. My family visits his farm twice a year for a picnic in the spring and a barbeque in the autumn. I get the satisfaction of knowing I am helping this farmer stay in business even when it’s difficult. If a late frost destroys the strawberry crop, he and I both go without (yes, I count that a benefit.) I feel like a part of the farm community. The farmer shares interesting recipes and ideas for using his crops. I very often find a treat in my share, like a gigantic sunflower to decorate my dining table. The biggest benefit: The vegetables in my share were harvested the day I received them. The same day. The tomatoes aren’t picked green and “gassed,” they are still warm from the sunshine.
I find the total I pay for these veggies is approximately equivalent to what I would pay in a major grocery store for organic produce. The overriding benefits of freshness, knowing the farmer personally and being a part of my food’s history outweigh the negatives of limited variety (if you call strawberries, broccoli, green onions, kale, collard greens, turnip greens, radishes, lettuces, blueberries, tomatoes, bell peppers, a variety of hot peppers, squash, zucchini, eggplant, melons, Irish potatoes, turnips, beets, sweet potatoes and cabbage, limited variety.) If I ever have a major resurgence of health combined with a move out of the city, I would possibly grow more of my own food and not rely so heavily on my CSA farmer. Otherwise, it would be a hard investment to forgo.
My dairy CSA full share provides me one gallon of fresh, raw milk every two weeks for 3 months. I pay the farmer $60 for each full share every three months.
I know the farmer who produces the milk my children drink. I have spoken to the cows themselves, looked into their shining eyes and seen their healthy coats. They roam pastures of green grass in yellow sunshine. I can ask the farmer about rotational grazing, “activator X” and silage and she actually knows what I’m talking about. I can ask her to bring me a kombucha mushroom with my next order or sample eggs gathered that day from her flock. I know my milk isn’t being “fortified” with dry milk powder, melamine or imported milk protein concentrates.
Fresh, raw milk is not available in any grocery store in my state. I can buy pasteurized, homogenized, fortified, weeks-old milk for about half the price of fresh, raw from my farmer. But, after doing research into what milk is and what happens to it in those “improving processes,” as long as I have an option, I’ll never go back.
My meat CSA full share provides me 20-22 pounds of grass-fed and finished beef, lamb, goat and chickens once a week for 24 consecutive weeks. I pay the farmer $650 in May.
Again, I know these animals. I know the names given them by the farmer’s children. I’ve seen their healthy eyes and coats, their beaks and feathers and learned about the lives they lead. I’ve seen their pasture and been introduced to their vet. My single regret is that when butchering time comes, they are not butchered according to Kosher law, a vastly superior method to what is deemed acceptable by American law. But, this is a small concession to the “Feds” who oversee that part of the operation. I am comfortable with the less-than-ideal butchering practice because I know my food is coming from healthy cattle, grazed on grass and bathed in sunshine instead of genetically altered, ill, captive animals fed foods their bodies can’t digest until they are large enough to slaughter.
While $4 a pound might seem expensive for meat, this price is comparable to the “organic” meat in my grocer’s dairy case. And “organic” does not mean grassfed. There are organic CAFOs just like there are conventional CAFOs. This is by far the best value for my dollar.
Expensive? Perhaps, but in the words of Joel Salatin, “If you think organic food is expensive, have you priced cancer lately?”
To find a CSA near you, please visit Local Harvest.



10 comments
Comments feed for this article
March 19, 2009 at 9:47 pm
Courtney
I love CSA’s I live in the midwest but mine organic box cost 300 for about 20 weeks, I think it truly is a better deal than the grocery store and you cant beat eating local and knowing how everything is done!
i was just looking into doing a meat today, i dont eat a lot of meat but if I do I want to know it is grass fed and no hormones, worth the extra cost to know what I am eating is clean.
March 19, 2009 at 10:00 pm
FoodRenegade
We do a CSA for veggies, and buy our meat in bulk from a local farmer. Really, $4/lb only sounds expensive when you’re thinking of ground beef. It isn’t expensive when you realize that’s every kind of cut under the sun — even the “expensive” ones like steaks or tenderloins or prime rib.
Thanks for your post!
March 19, 2009 at 10:13 pm
Kari
I’ve heard about CSA’s but never known anyone who was part of one or exactly how they work or how to go about finding one. Thank you for posting about them:)
March 19, 2009 at 10:18 pm
Kelly the Kitchen Kop
Wow, that was a very well-written post and I’m thinking about where I can link to it on my blog…by golly I’ll find a spot or create one.
Thanks!
Kelly
March 20, 2009 at 5:19 am
Lisa
wow- that would be so wonderful! I will be looking into to seeing if Nova Scotia has anything similar, although I have a funny feeling they don’t. Unfortunately our growing season is a lot shorter and farmers much more sparse. Our first step was to get a food box delivery service, which is highly reputable here in Halifax and still affordable, but still not as connected to the farmer as you are!
I do really like the CSA for produce- I don’t have 700$ to drop at one time, but your post definitely was so thoughtfully written; causing me to pause and consider
Thank you for that!
March 20, 2009 at 8:21 am
motherhen68
Good post! We’ve just recently joined our area’s CSA for veggies. We came to it in the middle of December (we live in SW Louisiana 12 month growing seasons). To be honest, I was a bit disappointed in the amount of produce I received. I am giving the CSA the benefit of the doubt and I have purchased a full share for the spring/summer season. I’m hoping we get more than what we did in the winter. I was barely receiving enough for one meal for 4 (ie: lettuce for salad, etc). I’m not trying to be ugly, but I think the CSA board stretched themselves a bit too far and sold too many shares.
On the up side, they have moved to a much much larger location. Rather than the previous plot, which was about the size of a backyard garden (a really dedicated backyard gardener!), they’ve planted their summer crop in a 5 acre plot. I’m keeping my fingers crossed. I really really really want to support something like this, but at the same time, I don’t want to feel like I”m just throwing my money away.
And can I be honest? I weep with jealousy of your CSA for milk and milk products. You lucky duck! Even that price is not expensive for great raw milk. We are not allowed to “legally” purchase raw milk here in this state. Some farmers go around it and sell it to us for “our pet’s food”. I believe there is a “cow share” program, but it’s miles from me and totally on the other side of the parish. I’ve never even called because I figured the cost would just be out of the world. I think I’ll give her a call though.
March 21, 2009 at 6:45 pm
localnourishment
I’m in the same situation with raw milk. They call it “pet milk” here, too. It’s so funny to see things like “raw cream cheese for PET USE ONLY”! Oooh, thanks so much, my dogs LOVE your creme fraiche!
March 20, 2009 at 4:27 pm
Lee
What a great, compelling post. I’ve recently joined a CSA for the first time (I’m in MN, blogging about it too), and you’ve done such a great job of articulating the true benefits and costs. Thank you.
May 28, 2009 at 10:59 pm
Jean
Nice post. I linked to it on mine about food shopping. Hope you don’t mind! http://www.mindfuleats.com/mindfuleats/2009/05/shopping.html
May 29, 2009 at 8:29 am
localnourishment
No, I don’t mind! Thank you!