This post is part of the NO-GMO Challenge Blog Carnival.

You’d think the boy cut his teeth on Skippy. He didn’t. Really! When my oldest three were young, we only ate natural, organic, homemade food. Not traditional so much, but never fast food and rarely processed food. The only peanut butter he knew until he was 10 was the kind you grind yourself at the health food store. Just peanuts. I even had an attachment to my food processor that would make dandy PB before it died.
I came home with the ONLY peanut butter in the store I could locate that didn’t have cottonseed, soy or canola oil in it: a glass jar of Smucker’s Organic. Even the store organic brand had sugar in it. Of course, the Smucker’s had a layer of oil floating on top, something I knew John would NOT stand for. So, I dumped it into a bowl and hit it with the handblender for a few seconds. Knowing our track record with kids handling glass jars and injury, I set it out for recycling and scooped the mixed PB into the plastic Skippy jar that was nearly empty. I wasn’t home to explain the switch when he got out the jar to make his before-bed sandwich.
You would think I committed a felony. John was not pleased that: 1) I “substituted this junk for real peanut butter,” 2) Didn’t tell him of the switch, and 3) “hid it in my Skippy jar like I was a two-year-old.”
I like the idea of replacing the things you eat most with the healthiest possible versions. John eats his way through a 16 ounce jar of peanut butter two or three times a week. Switching it out for organic, no GMO peanut butter with no added sugar would really benefit him. And I know once he gets used to it, the other stuff won’t taste right anymore. But getting there sure can be an uphill climb!

The Dark Side of Fat Loss
7 comments
Comments feed for this article
April 27, 2009 at 10:17 am
CHEESESLAVE
It’s hard with older kids because they get used to eating a certain way, don’t they?
Whole Foods makes a good organic peanut butter. It’s got palm oil in it is o it’s a lot creamier. And palm oil is good for you. Just an idea!
April 27, 2009 at 10:18 am
CHEESESLAVE
By the way I stumbled your post!
April 27, 2009 at 1:11 pm
localnourishment
Aw, thanks! I don’t think I’ve ever been stumbled before!
April 27, 2009 at 1:46 pm
sustainableeats
Loved your post – and dreading the day when my two boys can eat that much food!
April 27, 2009 at 5:06 pm
Rose
Lol, I did something similar to that to my sister. I bought a bottle of water when I was out and then refilled it with filtered water and kept it in the fridge. While she was visiting she would search out the fridge for the bottled water I kept refilling instead of using the filtered tap I filled it from.
I don’t think she ever realized the difference. (Since switched to a nice BPA free water bottle.)
I love the MaraNatha creamy organic… but mainly cause it doesn’t taste like skippy.
Maybe mix half/half skippy and healthy stuff next time… and then each time switch it to more and more the healthy stuff?
April 27, 2009 at 5:53 pm
localnourishment
Good idea on the half and half. I love Maranatha PB, too!
April 28, 2009 at 9:01 am
Kelly the Kitchen Kop
Oh, I sooooooooo feel your pain. We corrupted our teen’s palate early on with all the junk we gave him and it has been an uphill battle getting him to like the good stuff!